This Colorado Pizza’s Crispy Cheese Edge Has A Cult Following

This is not your average neighborhood pizza joint. From the moment you walk in, the friendly and knowledgeable service sets the tone for a top-tier dining experience. Patrons rave about the unique ambiance and the incredible quality of the food, calling it the most delicious pizza they’ve ever had. It’s the kind of place that turns even a pizza skeptic into a lifelong fan.

The star of the show is undeniably the pizza, which is so much more than just dough and cheese. The crust is a masterpiece of texture, offering a perfect contrast with the flavorful toppings and high-quality cheese. Whether you crave a thick, bready slice or the thinnest, crispiest crust imaginable, there’s a style here to satisfy you. The menu is so extensive that the hardest part of the visit is choosing just one pie, but that’s a great reason to come back again and again.

This culinary gem, where one visitor’s Italian-descended partner declared it the best pizza outside of Naples, is Blue Pan Pizza. It has secured its spot as a go-to destination for anyone seeking an unforgettable meal, from the signature pies to the fresh, vibrant salads that perfectly complement them.

What We Love

Detroit-Style Perfection

The Detroit-style pizza is the signature offering and an absolute must-try. Reviewers consistently describe it as “to die for,” praising the thick, bread-like base and the perfectly crisped, cheesy crust edges. The contrast in texture and the rich flavor profile make it a truly memorable experience that will have you planning your next visit before you’ve even left.

Fantastic Service & Ambiance

This is a self-described “fancier pizza joint,” and the experience lives up to it. Guests are greeted with cloth napkins and attentive, friendly service from a staff that knows the menu inside and out. The ambiance is lively and cool, with fun decor like Detroit sports memorabilia that adds to the unique character of the space.

Kevin L. / Yelp

A Style for Everyone

While the Detroit style gets the most attention, the extensive menu caters to every pizza preference. For thin-crust aficionados, the Tavern style is celebrated for being incredibly thin and crispy. For those who prefer a classic hand-tossed pie, the New York style offers a soft, puffy end crust. This wide variety ensures that everyone at the table can find their perfect slice.

Menu Highlights

Atmosphere & Setting

Located in Denver’s popular Highlands neighborhood, Blue Pan Pizza has a “downtown core” ambiance that is both fun and inviting. The interior is decorated with cool Detroit sports memorabilia, adding a touch of personality and a nod to the origins of its signature pizza style. The atmosphere strikes a perfect balance between a casual pizza parlor and an upscale restaurant, making it suitable for a date night or a family meal.

Pui-See Y. / Yelp

The physical space is well-designed, offering a comfortable dining experience. During warmer months, the restaurant opens up to provide an indoor/outdoor setting that is perfect for enjoying a summer evening. This thoughtful touch, combined with its prime location, makes it a true neighborhood staple.

Value (Is It Worth It?)

Blue Pan is a “fancier pizza joint,” and its prices reflect the significant step up in quality from a standard pizzeria. While it may not be the cheapest option, the value is undeniable. The portions are filling, and the quality of the ingredients, from the fresh salad vegetables to the premium pizza toppings, is consistently high.

Ultimately, you are paying for an exceptional culinary product that many have called the “best pizza” they’ve ever had. When considering the expert craftsmanship, the delicious and unique offerings, and the excellent service, a meal at Blue Pan Pizza is absolutely worth the cost. It’s an investment in a memorable dining experience.

Insider Tips

With such a large menu, choosing can be tough. If you’re overwhelmed, know that you can’t go wrong with their signature Detroit style, and they even offer it in a personal size if you’re dining solo or want to sample multiple things. For thin crust lovers, the Tavern style is the thinnest, but be aware it doesn’t come in a small size, so be ready for delicious leftovers.

The restaurant is a popular spot, but the takeout is just as good as dining in. One reviewer noted their takeout order “didn’t disappoint,” making it a fantastic option if you want to enjoy world-class pizza from the comfort of your home without waiting for a table.

Lauren R. / Yelp

Don’t let the thought of parking in the Highlands deter you from visiting. A helpful review points out that street parking is “readily available” near the restaurant. This makes a visit much more convenient and removes a common headache associated with dining in popular urban neighborhoods.

For an elevated pizza experience that goes above and beyond, Blue Pan Pizza is a standout. With its incredible variety of crusts, top-notch ingredients, and a cool, welcoming vibe, it has rightfully earned its place as one of Denver’s most beloved restaurants. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, this is one meal you won’t soon forget.