There’s A Caramelized Pizza Crust In Colorado That People Are Calling A Game Changer

Diners consistently rave about the friendly, knowledgeable service and the incredible pizza that can convert even the most skeptical eaters. The signature Detroit-style pies are frequently described as “to die for,” with a perfect crust that provides a stunning contrast in texture and flavor. It’s the kind of place that creates loyal customers, with many vowing it will become their new go-to spot for a pizza fix.

Beyond the famous thick-crust pizza, the menu offers an impressive variety that caters to all tastes. Whether you’re a fan of the thinnest, crispiest Tavern-style crust or a more traditional New York hand-tossed slice, you’ll find an option to love. The menu is so extensive that it can be hard to choose, but with high-quality ingredients and unique flavor combinations like Mike’s Hot Honey, every choice is a good one.

This local hotspot, praised as serving some of the best pizza outside of Naples, is none other than Blue Pan Pizza. Located in the Highlands neighborhood of Denver, it has built a stellar reputation on its incredible food, great service, and welcoming ambiance. From the cloth napkins to the curated beer list, it’s a dining experience that feels both special and comfortable.

What We Love

The Famous Detroit-Style Crust

The star of the show is the authentic Detroit-style pizza. Baked in rectangular blue steel pans, the dough rises into a thick, airy, and light crust. The magic happens at the edges, where brick cheese is spread to the very-end, creating a caramelized, crispy, and unbelievably flavorful cheese frico crust that is simply unforgettable.

Pizza for Every Preference

While the Detroit-style gets most of the glory, the menu doesn’t stop there. For those who prefer a thinner bite, the Tavern style offers a super-thin, cracker-like crispy crust. There’s also a classic New York style that’s more puffy and soft. This dedication to variety ensures that every pizza lover in your group will leave happy.

Kevin L. / Yelp

Top-Tier Service

The experience is elevated by service that receives as much praise as the food. Staff are described as friendly, sweet, and knowledgeable, guiding guests through the extensive menu with a smile. This welcoming attitude makes the “downtown core ambience” feel even more inviting and is a key reason diners return again and again.

Menu Highlights

Atmosphere & Setting

The restaurant strikes a perfect balance between a casual pizzeria and a more upscale dining spot. Reviewers note the “fancier” touches like cloth napkins and a nice beer and wine list, all within a comfortable and lively setting. The “downtown core ambience” makes it feel modern and cool, suitable for a date night or a fun meal with friends.

Kendra S. / Yelp

Located conveniently in the Highlands neighborhood, the space itself is well-designed with a welcoming interior and a cozy bar area. During pleasant weather, the indoor/outdoor seating offers a perfect dining experience, allowing guests to enjoy the evening air. The overall vibe is bustling and happy, reflecting a place that is clearly a beloved neighborhood staple.

Value (Is It Worth It?)

Absolutely. While it may be a “fancier pizza joint” than a standard slice shop, the value is evident in every bite. The portion sizes are generous – so much so that leftovers for breakfast are a common and celebrated occurrence. The quality of the ingredients, from the imported cheeses to the fresh toppings, justifies the price point.

Considering the unique and expertly crafted pizza styles, the excellent service, and the enjoyable atmosphere, Blue Pan Pizza delivers a premium experience that feels well worth the cost. It’s an investment in a genuinely memorable meal that consistently lives up to its glowing reputation.

Insider Tips

The menu is packed with delicious but numerous options, which can feel overwhelming for a first-timer. To avoid decision paralysis when you arrive, it’s a great idea to check out the menu on their website beforehand. This way, you can ponder the many styles and toppings and arrive ready to order.

Crystal R. / Yelp

If you’re dining solo or simply don’t want to commit to a large pizza, the Detroit-style is your best friend. It’s the only style that comes in a personal/small size, making it perfect for an individual meal. In contrast, the thin Tavern-style pizza doesn’t have a small option, so be prepared to share or enjoy leftovers the next day. Also, don’t fret about parking; reviewers note that street parking is typically easy to find.

For those who’d rather enjoy top-tier pizza at home, the take-out service is highly recommended. The pizzas travel well, ensuring you get the same great quality you would in the restaurant. It’s a fantastic option for a cozy night in without compromising on a high-quality meal.

For an unforgettable pizza experience in Denver, Blue Pan Pizza is a clear winner. Its mastery of the coveted Detroit style, combined with a diverse menu and a warm, inviting atmosphere, makes it a must-visit destination. Whether you dine in or take out, you’re in for a treat that will have you planning your next visit before you’ve even finished your last slice.