There’s a reason why patrons are calling this the best pizza they’ve ever had, even comparing it favorably to authentic Neapolitan pies. The star of the show is the Detroit-style pizza, celebrated for its “to die for” crust that achieves a perfect, crispy, cheesy caramelization around the edges while maintaining a light, airy interior. The contrast in texture and the rich flavor profile have made converts out of even the most skeptical pizza eaters.
Beyond the phenomenal pies, the service consistently receives high praise for being friendly, knowledgeable, and genuinely sweet. Diners appreciate the guidance through the impressively large menu, which some describe as having almost too many delicious choices. This combination of stellar food and welcoming staff creates an experience that keeps people coming back for more.
The ambiance is often described as having a cool, “downtown core” vibe that’s both nice and well-located, with readily available street parking. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout, the quality remains top-notch. For a truly memorable meal that lives up to the hype, look no further than Blue Pan Pizza.
What We Love
The Authentic Detroit-Style Crust
The foundation of any great pizza is its crust, and here it’s an absolute masterpiece. The Detroit-style pizza features a thick, rectangular crust with a fluffy, focaccia-like interior and, most importantly, a crispy, cheesy edge formed by baking the pizza in well-oiled pans. This signature “frico” crust provides an irresistible textural contrast that has diners dreaming about their next visit.
An Impressively Vast Menu
While famous for the Detroit style, the menu’s breadth is a major draw. Reviewers note that the menu is “pretty extensive,” offering Chicago Cracker Thin, Classic Italian, and New York Style slices as well. This variety ensures there’s something for every preference, from classic combinations to unique creations like the “Little Rose” with ricotta and hot honey, making the decision of what to order a delightful challenge.
Exceptional and Friendly Service
A great meal is made even better by great service, and the staff here consistently delivers. Patrons describe the servers as “the sweetest gal ever” and “friendly, knowledgeable.” This warm and attentive service makes diners feel welcome and well-cared for, turning a simple pizza dinner into a genuinely pleasant dining experience from start to finish.
Menu Highlights
Louis Style Pizzas
For those who prefer a lighter, crispier base, the Louis Style is an excellent choice. This pizza features an impossibly thin, cracker-like crust that provides a satisfying crunch with every bite. It’s the perfect canvas for a variety of toppings, allowing their flavors to shine through without being weighed down by heavy dough.
Detroit Style Pizza
This is the signature item that has earned the restaurant its legendary status. Baked in rectangular blue steel pans, the dough becomes airy and light while the cheese melts down the sides, creating a deeply caramelized, crunchy crust. It’s a substantial and incredibly flavorful pizza that is often described as the best version many have ever tasted.
Brooklyn Bridge
A fan-favorite mentioned by name in reviews, the Brooklyn Bridge is a must-try for first-time visitors. This Detroit-style pizza is loaded with natural casing pepperoni, Italian sausage, and ricotta cheese, creating a rich and savory flavor profile. It perfectly showcases the restaurant’s ability to balance premium toppings with their iconic crust.
Parma Italia
This pizza offers a taste of classic Italy with high-quality ingredients that speak for themselves. The Parma Italia is typically topped with delicate prosciutto, fresh arugula, and savory parmesan, offering a more refined and lighter flavor profile. It’s a fantastic choice for those who appreciate the simple elegance of Italian-inspired toppings.
Sweetie Pie
An ode to sweet and savory combinations, this pie often features ingredients like fig preserve, prosciutto, and a balsamic glaze. It’s a gourmet experience that pushes the boundaries of traditional pizza. This is the kind of unique and memorable option that makes the extensive menu so exciting to explore.
Atmosphere & Setting
The restaurant strikes a balance between a casual neighborhood pizzeria and a cool, modern hangout. The vibe is lively and welcoming, making it an ideal spot for a date night, a family dinner, or a gathering with friends. Its location in the Highlands is convenient, and the ambiance inside feels both cozy and bustling, reflecting its popularity.
During warmer months, the indoor/outdoor seating options are a major plus, allowing diners to enjoy the beautiful weather. The space is well-designed, with a comfortable bar area and distinct dining spaces that feel intimate despite the restaurant’s energy. Even the bathroom gets a nod for being cool, showing an attention to detail throughout the entire establishment.
Value (Is It Worth It?)
Absolutely. While not the cheapest pizza in town, the value is exceptional. The quality of the ingredients, the sheer deliciousness of the final product, and the generous, filling portions make it worth every penny. Patrons consistently state their intention to return, with many crowning it the “best pizza in Denver.” When a single slice can be so memorable and satisfying, the price feels more than justified. It’s an investment in a top-tier culinary experience.
Insider Tips
Given its popularity, ordering ahead for takeout is a fantastic and convenient option. The system is streamlined, allowing you to get your hands on their incredible pizza without a long wait, which is especially helpful on busy weekend nights. Many regulars take advantage of this to enjoy the pies at home.
Don’t hesitate to explore beyond the pizza menu. The Greek salad was specifically highlighted by a reviewer for the freshness of its ingredients, making it a great starter or a lighter counterpoint to the rich pizza. Also, be adventurous with your pizza choices; combinations involving unique ingredients like Mike’s Hot Honey come highly recommended and are part of what makes the menu so special.
In short, Blue Pan Pizza delivers on all fronts: incredible, authentic Detroit-style pizza, a diverse menu with something for everyone, and warm, friendly service. It has rightfully earned its place as a go-to spot and a cornerstone of the local food scene, making it a must-try for residents and visitors alike.
Leave A Comment