Diners are consistently blown away by a particular style of pizza that is, for many, the best they have ever tasted. The crust is a frequent topic of praise, described as perfectly crispy with an incredible contrast of cheese and flavor. It’s so good, in fact, that it has converted self-proclaimed non-pizza fans and has even been declared by one visitor to be the best pizza they’ve had outside of Naples, Italy.
Beyond the phenomenal food, the service receives high marks for being friendly, sweet, and knowledgeable. The atmosphere is described as a nice, cool downtown core ambiance, making for a pleasant dining experience whether you’re a local or just visiting. The combination of exceptional food and welcoming staff makes it a standout destination.
This will easily become your go-to spot for a pizza fix. The menu is extensive, offering a wide variety of unique choices that can make it hard to decide, but you can’t go wrong. For a truly memorable meal that even impresses those with the highest standards, you have to visit Blue Pan Pizza.
What We Love
The Unforgettable Detroit-Style Crust
The star of the show is undoubtedly the Detroit-style pizza. Its thick, rectangular crust achieves a perfect, crispy texture with caramelized cheese baked into the edges. Reviewers consistently rave about this signature element, calling it “to die for” and the foundation of a fantastic flavor profile.
An Impressively Extensive Menu
While famous for its Detroit-style pies, the menu is large and packed with creative options. This variety ensures there’s something for every palate, from different pizza styles to fresh, delicious salads. The sheer number of choices can be almost overwhelming, but it’s a testament to their culinary creativity.
Friendly and Knowledgeable Staff
The experience is elevated by the wonderful service. The staff is frequently described as friendly, sweet, and genuinely knowledgeable about the menu. This welcoming attitude makes diners feel right at home and contributes to the restaurant’s stellar reputation.
Menu Highlights
Louis Style Pizzas
For those who prefer a more traditional pizza experience, the St. Louis style offers a cracker-thin crust that’s cut into shareable squares. This style provides a lighter, crispier alternative to the deep-dish Detroit pies, allowing the fresh toppings to shine through.
Detroit Style Pizza
This is the signature, must-try item that has earned the restaurant its fame. Baked in rectangular blue steel pans, these pizzas feature a thick, airy crust, a wall of crispy caramelized cheese around the edge, and sauce ladled on top. It’s a filling and incredibly flavorful experience.
Brooklyn Bridge
A fan favorite, the Brooklyn Bridge is a masterpiece of flavor built on a Detroit-style crust. It’s topped with pepperoni, Italian sausage, and ricotta cheese, creating a rich, savory, and satisfying combination that customers dream about long after their visit.
Parma Italia
This pizza offers a taste of Italy with a sophisticated profile. It typically features delicate prosciutto, sharp parmesan, and fresh arugula, providing a delicious contrast of salty, peppery, and savory notes. It’s a perfect choice for those seeking a more refined flavor combination.
Sweetie Pie
Inspired by a review mentioning a pizza with Mike’s Hot Honey, the Sweetie Pie likely balances sweet and savory elements. Expect ingredients that might include a sweet component like fig jam or honey paired with salty meats and creamy cheeses for a unique and addictive taste.
Atmosphere & Setting
The restaurant boasts a “downtown core ambience” that is both cool and inviting. It’s a well-located spot within the Highlands neighborhood that feels modern and comfortable, making it an ideal setting for a casual dinner with friends, a family meal, or a date night. The vibe is lively without being overwhelming, centered around the appreciation of great pizza.
The space itself offers flexibility, with a welcoming interior that includes a bar area perfect for a quick bite. During warmer months, the availability of indoor/outdoor seating creates a perfect summer evening dining experience. The layout is thoughtfully designed to accommodate both dine-in customers and a steady stream of takeout orders efficiently.
Value (Is It Worth It?)
Absolutely. While premium pizza comes at a premium price, the value here is undeniable. The Detroit-style pizzas are described as “so filling” that a single pie goes a long way, and many reviewers even enjoy the leftovers for breakfast the next day. The quality of the ingredients, from the fresh salads to the toppings on the pizza, is consistently highlighted.
When customers declare it the “best pizza” they’ve ever had, it’s clear the experience is worth the cost. You’re not just paying for a meal; you’re paying for a top-tier culinary creation that delivers on its promise of being exceptionally delicious and memorable. It’s a worthy splurge for any pizza lover.
Insider Tips
Don’t hesitate to get your order to-go. Multiple reviews confirm that the takeout quality is just as high as the dine-in experience, with one person noting their pizza “didn’t disappoint.” This makes it a perfect option for a delicious night in.
Restaurant exterior on Highland. Order ahead and pick up your food without ever going inside! Very COVID-friendly.
The restaurant has a streamlined pickup system, allowing you to order ahead and grab your food without a long wait. Given the large menu, it’s a good idea to look it over online before you call or arrive. This helps avoid the delightful but difficult decision of what to choose on the spot. Finally, consider adding a salad to your order; the Greek salad was specifically praised for the freshness of its ingredients.
With its legendary Detroit-style pies, extensive menu, and friendly service, this spot has rightfully earned its place as one of the best pizza joints in Denver. It’s a must-visit for anyone seeking a truly exceptional and satisfying meal that will have you dreaming of its crispy, cheesy crust.
Leave A Comment