We Found The Most Talked-About Detroit-Style Pizza Hiding in a Charming Colorado Neighborhood

There’s a place that has locals and visitors buzzing, with some patrons claiming it’s not just the best pizza in the city, but the best they’ve ever had. The praise is extraordinary, with one diner whose Italian-born father declared it the best pizza he’s eaten outside of Naples, Italy.

The style that earns such high acclaim is the Detroit-style pizza. It’s a culinary masterpiece, known for its thick, rectangular crust that’s simultaneously light and airy on the inside and perfectly crisp on the outside. The magic is in the pan, which creates a caramelized cheese crust around the edges that is simply to die for.

This celebrated pizzeria that has everyone talking and dreaming of their next slice is none other than Blue Pan Pizza. The combination of friendly, knowledgeable service and a truly unforgettable product makes it a standout destination.

What We Love

The undeniable star is the authentic Detroit-style pizza, featuring a thick, airy crust with a perfectly caramelized, frico cheese edge that is utterly addictive. Beyond the incredible foundation, the quality of the ingredients shines through, from the flavorful sauce to inventive and beloved additions like Mike’s Hot Honey that elevate each pie from great to exceptional.

Kevin L. / Yelp

This world-class pizza experience is supported by consistently friendly and knowledgeable service. The staff’s welcoming attitude enhances the meal, making you feel right at home as you indulge in what might be the best pizza of your life.

Menu Highlights

Atmosphere & Setting

The restaurant exudes a cozy and bustling neighborhood vibe. It feels both like a special occasion spot and a comfortable local hangout, striking a perfect balance that welcomes everyone. The energy is lively and adds to the overall memorable experience of the meal.

Pui-See Y. / Yelp

The interior is warm and inviting, though it can get busy due to its popularity. The bar area offers a great vantage point and a more casual setting for enjoying a slice and a drink. The space is well-kept and contributes to the premium yet unpretentious feel.

Value (Is It Worth It?)

Absolutely. While you might pay more than you would at a standard pizza chain, the cost is a direct reflection of the superior quality. Diners consistently feel they are getting what they pay for: an exceptional, thoughtfully prepared meal using high-end ingredients. The unforgettable taste and rave reviews confirm that Blue Pan Pizza offers a premium experience that is well worth the price for a truly special treat.

Insider Tips

Don’t be afraid to try one of the signature combinations like the Brooklyn Bridge, which has earned a cult following. The single most mentioned tip from regulars is to add Mike’s Hot Honey to your order; it’s a transformative addition that pairs perfectly with the savory pepperoni and cheesy crust.

Lauren R. / Yelp

If the restaurant is packed or you’re planning a night in, the takeout is a fantastic and highly recommended option. Reviews confirm that the pizza travels remarkably well, delivering the same incredible flavor and texture that you’d get dining in. It’s a perfect way to enjoy this top-tier pizza from the comfort of your home.

For first-timers and seasoned pizza lovers alike, Blue Pan Pizza delivers on its promise of an extraordinary meal. Whether you’re a skeptic of Detroit-style pizza or a lifelong fan, this restaurant has a high probability of becoming your new favorite. It’s a must-visit culinary destination that absolutely lives up to the hype.